Choosing a Share Portfolio manager – part II

OK, so from narrowing my choice down to four (Stockopedia, Sharesight, Yahoo Finance and Google Finance) I’ve immediately managed to rule out Yahoo and Google for a couple of reasons:

Very basic functionality. No obvious way to account for cash or dividends or transaction costs. These I’d class as essential to managing a Portfolio. I’ve done a quick Google (!) on both and cannot see any way of doing this, so have abandoned them, each with one test transaction.

Sharesight

So far:

  • + Automatically adds dividends – nice

  • – Need upgraded package to manage cash balances
  • – Portfolio only shows % returns, not £££. Have to drill down into a share to see this. Correction. Just fond a toggle to do this.
  • – Cannot benchmark against an index, only an ETF
  • – Cannot configure columns in Portfolio
  • – Can’t check out Reporting without upgrade
  • – CSV imports are limited to buys and sells. My existing Portfolio is stuffed with other transactions, so looks like they won’t be importable
  • – Not obvious from a Portfolio summary that a share has a comment note made

I *think* I can produce a report showing each shareholding’s portion of the whole Portfolio, but it’s in the Premium section and I can’t actually see any examples in their Help section, or Online.

Stockopedia

So far:

  • + Built into my current subscription so no extra cost
  • – Cannot produce a Report showing % of Portfolio per share
  • – Can add a note, but it’s not visible from the Portfolio summary

As I wasn’t happy, I did run another Google search and came up with:

Morningstar – very limited features

ThisIsMoney – ditto

Trustnet – Not a good User Interface (UI) and when I tried to add CEY it wasn’t on the list and therefore I couldn’t add it.

In the end I have plumped for Stockopedia in that it has decent functionality and I’m already paying for the subscription. It’s taken me a few hours to import my data from StockMarketEye – quirks at both end of the Export / Import process, but significantly quicker than manually typing in all those transactions again. reporting on this Blog may look a bit different. I’ll cross that bridge when I come to it as, at the moment I have no spare cash for purchases and nothing looks worthy of being sold. Watch this space.

Choosing a Share Portfolio manager – part I

What Share Portfolio manager should I choose?

At the moment I use Stockmarket Eye which, when it is working, is great for my needs (live-ish prices, charting, historic data, multiple portfolios). However, it has not been working for one reason or another since May and there is no sign of a solution on the horizon.

I have subscribed to Stockopedia, which has Portfolio Management amongst its features. However it has nowhere near as many Portfolio features as Stockmarket Eye. The hunt is on for a new package.

Requirements for a Share Portfolio Manager package:

  • Live and historic data for charting. Live with a delay is absolutely fine for my purposes.
  • Multiple portfolio support
  • Index comparisons
  • Gain / loss calculations
  • Colour coding for gains / losses etc. You don’t realise how helpful this is until you don’t have it.
  • Reasonable price – not expecting something for free, although a limited free trial is really helpful to get a feel for the features.

The (very) short list

After a quick Google I’ve come up with the following:

  • SharePad by Sharescope
  • Sharesight
  • Yahoo Finance
  • Google Finance

SharePad

This appears to be very akin to my current Stockopedia Subscription. Prices, charting, analysis, ratios and screens etc. Portfolio Management seems to be a very small subset. Parked for now. £32 / m or £347 / y

Sharesight

Touts itself just as a Portfolio tracker.

Automatically track price, performance and dividends from 240,000+ global stocks, crypto, ETFs and funds. Add cash accounts and property to get the full picture of your portfolio – all in one place.

Pricing plans: There are 4, starting at Free forever

  • Free forever. £0. 1 Portfolio, 10 holdings
  • Starter £11 / £8.25. 1 Portfolio, 30 holdings
  • Investor £19 / £14.25 4 Portfolios, unlimited holdings
  • Expert £24 / £18 10 Portfolios, unlimited holdings

(pricing is monthly or monthly equivalent if you pay annually)

There are other features, too such as custom groups, so you can group your holdings by (say) Industry, country, investment type etc.

As I run two Portfolios, that means it will be the ‘investor’ package anyway, but actually I am currently on 30 holdings. If they count the same holdings in both portfolios as double then I’m above the 30 limit as well, anyway.

I’m going to subscribe to the free version just to have a play and report back.

Yahoo Finance

Interestingly (or not), Yahoo Finance is the source of the data for Stockmarket Eye and is also the source of its current angst as it has changed the way SME can extract data.

Either way, Yahoo Finance is a pretty comprehensive source of financial data so I’ll set up a parallel Portfolio to Sharesight and see how they compare.

Google Finance

Google also offers Portfolio services, so I’ll give that a try, too.


I’ll report back in Part II, but if anyone knows of any other UK-supporting share Portfolio management software, do let me know in the comments, below. Please don’t suggest anything Excel-based, however good as I really don’t trust the data capabilities. I would much rather pay for dedicated software.

Dominos (DOM) – Sell, Brickability (BRCK), VP (VP.) and Epwin (EPWN) buy

Dominos

Dominos leapt after a smashing set of results and it seemed rude to not take a 50%+ profit after just 6 months. I just think it’s got a bit ahead of itself now and hopefully it might sink back later in the year to buy back in again.

Sell price: @ £4.02
Buy price: £2.62
Dividend income: 2.5%

Gain: 55.5% total (2.5% + 53%) 130% pa (not compounded)

With the Dominos money burning a hole in my pocket I’ve been playing with the Stock Screening tool on Stockopedia. I’m looking for companies within 20% of their 52 week low, with a reasonable PER and PEG. Minimum size £20M although in practise I’m more comfortable with the £50M + Organisations. I also filtered out certain sectors as they are not for me. Pure exploration and Biotech for instance.

This threw up a list of about 120 and I trawled through the figures this weekend. This narrowed it down to a shortlist of about 40, which I then ranked, then had enough cash to purchase three of the top ones. Plenty more to purchase, just no cash to do so… ones that didn’t make the cut, for instance, include the Banks Barclays and tarnished NatWest.

Brickability

Brickability Group PLC is a United Kingdom-based construction materials distributor. The Company supplies facing bricks, blocks, rainscreen cladding systems, architectural masonry, paving, roof tiles and slates to the construction industry (Stockopedia)

Does what it says on the tin. Makes bricks. Income has grown rapidly in its 3 years of trading from £11m to £600m with profits of about 5-10%. Positive trading update and cost pressures are abating. Taken a modest stake as it’s a smaller than my normal size Organisation.

Buy @ 54.47p with a Dividend yield of 6% and PER of 5.4
Portfolio %: 2.2%
Total Portfolio Holdings: 2.2%

VP Group

Vp plc is a United Kingdom-based equipment rental specialist company. The Company provides specialist products and services to a diverse range of end markets, including infrastructure, construction, housebuilding, and energy (Stockopedia)

More steadily rising turnover and profit, but positive noises from the Management team. Brisk are not yet going out of fashion, especially with the drive for more affordable housing, whatever the colour of the Government over the next 5 years.

Buy @ £5.79 with a Dividend yield of 6.5% and a PER of 7
Portfolio %: 2.8%
Total Portfolio Holdings: 2.8%

Epwin Group

Epwin Group Plc is a manufacturer and supplier of energy efficient and low-maintenance building products, including windows, doors, and fascia systems. (Stockopedia)

Energy efficient”, “low maintenance”. Nice.

Trading Update end July:

Trading ahead of a strong 2022 comparative; confident of achieving full year expectations

and

Trading during the first half of 2023 was in line with the Board’s expectations. Revenues increased to approximately £180 million, with the Group continuing to trade ahead of a strong 2022 comparative.

Buy @ 72.3p with a Dividend yield of 6.2% and a PER of 7.3
Portfolio %: 2.2%
Total Portfolio Holdings: 2.2%


888 Reports next week (15th). It’s bounced back strongly and quickly since the sell-off after I sold, so it will be interesting to see whet the effects of interest rate rises have had on both its costs and the ability of its customers to place bets. I’m still cautious and, so far, it’s about 10% below my selling price.

I’ll update the Portfolio later this month.

This Blog must in no way be construed as investment advice. I’m not an Advisor, I’m just a Private Investor that takes an interest in Stocks and Shares as a way of increasing my standard of Living & having a bit of fun. Feel free to comment. All comments are Moderated before publication, keep them relevant, short and interesting otherwise they won’t be published. My Blog, my Rules.

Don’t make me responsible for any decisions that you make off the back of anything I write here. DYour Own Research. Capice?