OK, so from narrowing my choice down to four (Stockopedia, Sharesight, Yahoo Finance and Google Finance) I’ve immediately managed to rule out Yahoo and Google for a couple of reasons:
Very basic functionality. No obvious way to account for cash or dividends or transaction costs. These I’d class as essential to managing a Portfolio. I’ve done a quick Google (!) on both and cannot see any way of doing this, so have abandoned them, each with one test transaction.
Sharesight
So far:
- + Automatically adds dividends – nice
- – Need upgraded package to manage cash balances
- – Portfolio only shows % returns, not £££. Have to drill down into a share to see this. Correction. Just fond a toggle to do this.
- – Cannot benchmark against an index, only an ETF
- – Cannot configure columns in Portfolio
- – Can’t check out Reporting without upgrade
- – CSV imports are limited to buys and sells. My existing Portfolio is stuffed with other transactions, so looks like they won’t be importable
- – Not obvious from a Portfolio summary that a share has a comment note made
I *think* I can produce a report showing each shareholding’s portion of the whole Portfolio, but it’s in the Premium section and I can’t actually see any examples in their Help section, or Online.
Stockopedia
So far:
- + Built into my current subscription so no extra cost
- – Cannot produce a Report showing % of Portfolio per share
- – Can add a note, but it’s not visible from the Portfolio summary
As I wasn’t happy, I did run another Google search and came up with:
Morningstar – very limited features
ThisIsMoney – ditto
Trustnet – Not a good User Interface (UI) and when I tried to add CEY it wasn’t on the list and therefore I couldn’t add it.
In the end I have plumped for Stockopedia in that it has decent functionality and I’m already paying for the subscription. It’s taken me a few hours to import my data from StockMarketEye – quirks at both end of the Export / Import process, but significantly quicker than manually typing in all those transactions again. reporting on this Blog may look a bit different. I’ll cross that bridge when I come to it as, at the moment I have no spare cash for purchases and nothing looks worthy of being sold. Watch this space.